Overview

Victorian Elegance Meets Bayshore Lifestyle at 57 Maple Avenue

Set on a quiet, tree-lined, no-parking street just steps from Bay Shore’s vibrant Main Street, this timeless 1930s Victorian offers more than charm — it offers flexibility, luxury, and serious lifestyle potential. Surrounded by lush, fenced-in grounds, the home is a true retreat in the heart of one of Suffolk County’s most walkable and thriving waterfront towns.

Inside, you'll find 4 spacious bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, original hardwood floors, intricate moldings, and a gracious layout with formal living and dining rooms, an inviting parlor with fireplace, and a sunny eat-in kitchen perfect for casual meals or hosting.

But what truly sets this property apart is the massive two-story garage — well over 1,000 square feet — built for the visionary. The first level features double-height ceilings, ideal for installing a lift and working on vehicles, or easily accommodating 4 to 8 cars. Whether you’re a car enthusiast, collector, or small business owner, this space is a dream. Upstairs, the second floor is currently set up as a recreational space, perfect for entertaining, working from home, or even converting into a legal rental or guest unit (with proper permits).

Add in the unbeatable location: just blocks from the ferry to Fire Island, the nightlife of Main Street, local breweries, waterfront dining, and the Bay Shore Marina. The no-parking street means a rare level of tranquility in such a central location.

Whether you're looking to live, work, play — or all three — this one-of-a-kind home delivers.